I was really disappointed with The Magpie Cafe after hearing such amazing things about it. I’ve had better food abd treatment in my local chippy in West Yorkshire. The first thing I noticed was the abrupt manner of the person on the door. Despite having booked I felt we were shown in abruptly and spoken to like we were riff raff. Secondly the quality of the Fish was appalling when we received our Fish and Chips. I ordered the medium fish and chips which was at best a very small fish. At £12 this was unbelievably overpriced. We also ordered a small fish which looked bigger than the medium fish and when we questioned it we were told it was a big ‘small’ fish which did not make any sense at all. The waitress that brought the food out was abrupt too. My plate arrived with a portion of mushy peas on the side which I had not ordered and to be honest don’t like. When I advised the waitress she abruptly said ‘it’s not touched your fish’! It’s safe to say I won’t be going there again. It feels like a place that has been incredibly successful in the past and has gotten complacent as a result of that success. The one pleasant and nice person was the waitress who was taking the orders. It felt like she was genuine and enjoyed her job.
Magpie Cafe – Whitby